Charlie Kaufman Explains I’m Considering of Ending Issues

Charlie Kaufman Explains I’m Thinking of Ending Things

If Kaufman’s enigmatic Netflix drama has you scratching your head, worry not: The director has solutions.

[Editor’s note: This article contains major spoilers about the plot of “I’m Thinking of Ending Things.”]

Charlie Kaufman shouldn’t be a fan of fixing films for his viewers. “I’m not really big on explaining what things are,” the writer-director stated in a telephone interview. “I let people have their experiences, so I don’t really have expectations about what people are going to think. I really do support anybody’s interpretation.”

However, nothing in Kaufman’s head-spinning repertoire has begged for solutions greater than “I’m Thinking of Ending Things.” His scripts for “Being John Malkovich” and “Adaptation” took weird labyrinthine paths into the troubled male psyche, a journey he continued with directing efforts “Synecdoche, New York” and “Anomalisa.” In his new Netflix-produced function, nevertheless, Kaufman has constructed a narrative steeped within the particulars of a single troubled thoughts, and littered it with so many reference factors it virtually calls for a masterclass in semiotics to parse all of them.

That’s by design. “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” pulls from Canadian author Iain Reid’s 2016 novel, however Kaufman has taken many liberties with the textual content, even because the fundamentals of the story stay unchanged: Jake (Jesse Plemons) takes new girlfriend Lucy (Jesse Buckley) on a snowy drive to satisfy his dad and mom (Toni Collette and David Thewlis). Because the title implies, Lucy, the narrator, has already thought-about dropping him. As this risk settles in, the couple endure a clumsy dinner, then depart for an icy drive dwelling that culminates with a detour to Jake’s highschool. Within the meantime, the varsity’s previous janitor (Man Boyd) roams these hallways in a lonely routine, ultimately crossing paths with the couple for a surreal climax.

That climax marks an enormous shift from the psychological thriller twist of Reid’s ebook, which takes a literal-minded flip to clarify the moments main as much as it. Kaufman has as a substitute bathed the entire film in ambiguous signifiers proper down the ultimate scene. “I don’t know if it was an epiphany or breakdown with ‘Adaptation,’ but since then, I’ve found that I’m most successful with adaptations when I allow myself to take it and do with it whatever makes sense to me,” he stated. “If I don’t allow that to happen, then I end up with something that feels dead to me.”

The result’s a dense, hypnotic narrative so overloaded with data that no first viewing can take up it in whole. Whereas “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” might baffle or frustrate viewers making an attempt to parse it from second to second, it additionally has a clear-cut sense of objective: Jake, whose childhood room is loaded with books, DVDs, and different detritus from his youth, has so absorbed the media surrounding him that it appears to manipulate each facet of his actuality. It isn’t mandatory to know each reference to understand this a part of the film, and even recognize its intent, however these mental pathways enrich the character of the enigma and reward repeat viewings.

Right here’s our official FAQ, with enter from Kaufman, for audiences desirous to study extra.

Truthful warning, if that spoiler alert up high hasn’t scared you off but: “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” advantages from the eerie puzzle-like nature of its design. If you happen to’d wish to retain that facet of it, strive watching it by itself phrases first, then double again to this breakdown to go deeper. In true Kaufmanesque type, these are our solutions to our personal questions; all of the quotes come from Kaufman.

Why does it seem to be Jake can hear Lucy’s ideas?

Within the opening sequence of the film, Jake and Lucy endure an interminable drive as much as his dad and mom’ home, whereas Lucy continues to ponder leaving him. On a number of events, Jake glances over to Lucy throughout her voiceover, typically interrupting it. Is he telepathic? The reply is definitely fairly easy. On the finish of Reid’s novel, it’s revealed that Jake and his unnamed girlfriend are the identical particular person — the lonely highschool janitor, who invented her as his fantasy. Assume “Psycho” meets “Fight Club.”

It doesn’t take lengthy for “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” to indicate as a lot. When Lucy, an aspiring poet, shares one among her verses on the dinner desk, it’s really a sampling from “Rotten Perfect Mouth,” a group of writings by real-life poet Eva H.D. Later within the film, it’s not even clear if Lucy’s identify is Lucy. (He calls her “Ames.” Amy?) Jake has constructed her out of the books, films, and passing encounters which have formed his remoted worldview.

So Lucy’s the primary character and she or he additionally doesn’t exist?

Nicely…sure and no. Probably the most subtle gamble of the film is that Kaufman has taken this machine and turned it into an open query: Can a fantasy exist by itself phrases?

“I’m Thinking of Ending Things”


“She is a device, but I wanted her to be able to separate himself from that,” Kaufman stated. “I didn’t want it to be a twist. I felt like that would not work in a movie at this point in history. When you make a movie, everything that’s sort of ambiguous becomes concrete. You’ve got people playing these things. You can see them.”

Evidently, Buckley turns in a wealthy, haunting efficiency as a lady grappling with the uncertainty surrounding her. “To my mind, it would have been a misuse of any actress not to give them something to play that was real,” Kaufman stated. “Because of the device that the book uses, it wasn’t required, and I needed it to be there.”

Nice, however that also doesn’t imply she’s an actual particular person.

Proper. However she has a particular consultant energy as Jake involves phrases with the impossibility of his delusion. At one level, he asks Lucy if she’s learn Anna Kavan’s 1967 novel “Ice,” which takes place in a post-apocalyptic wasteland (not in contrast to the dreary outside that encompass the film’s two huge automotive rides). The protagonist of “Ice” spends many of the ebook pursuing an unnamed girl whereas wrestling with the sophisticated nature of his attraction.

In “I’m Thinking of Ending Things,” the character endures that very same wrestle when the fantasy fights again. It’s a storytelling gamble distinctive to the artwork of cinema: Throughout the “world” of “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” — one managed by Kaufman in addition to his protagonist — Lucy exists. “I needed her to have agency for it to work as a dramatic piece,” Kaufman stated. “I really liked the idea that even within his fantasy, he cannot have what he wants. He’s going to imagine this thing, but then he’s going to also imagine how it won’t work, how she’s going to bored with him, how she’s going to not think he’s smart enough or interesting enough.”

Finally, Jake stops making an attempt to resolve his issues by inventing new folks, and as a substitute focuses on himself. “In keeping with the idea of giving her some agency, I didn’t want her to be responsible for his ending,” Kaufman stated.

At one level, the janitor watches the ending of a tacky romance that’s directed by Robert Zemeckis. The abrupt finish credit score is hilarious. However why Zemeckis?

The janitor is commonly a passive character in the highschool, absorbing faces and circumstances from the sidelines. Nevertheless, one scene finds him sitting in an empty room, consuming lunch and watching a film on tv. It’s the ultimate minutes of a tacky romance set in a diner, and the credit come up simply lengthy sufficient for one identify to seem: “Directed By Robert Zemeckis.”

Why did Kaufman determine to toss in a reference to the director of “The Polar Express”? Kaufman has been telling interviewers that it occurred at random, when his assistant director prompt it after perusing an inventory of director names on-line. Zemeckis wasn’t even in Kaufman’s unique model of the script.

“Sometimes things are funny because they’re funny, and I feel like it’s possible that Zemeckis could have made this movie, even if it’s unlikely,” Kaufman stated. On the identical time, there’s a contact of irony to the choice. “I don’t think Zemeckis ever has or ever would make a movie like this,” Kaufman stated. “It’s more like a Nancy Meyers movie. He wasn’t a model for it. His stuff is generally more high-concept, but it’s possible, so the joke resonates somehow.” He requested the director for permission to incorporate the reference, and Zemeckis is thanked within the credit.

So it was only a random alternative?

Yeah, that story sounds nearly too neat for its personal good, doesn’t it? In spite of everything, Zemeckis is likely one of the greatest industrial administrators of the previous 30 years, and Kaufman’s work is defiantly non-commercial. On high of that, Kaufman did at one level nearly work with the director when he tailored the younger grownup novel “Chaos Walking” manner again in 2012. The mission has gone by way of many writers since then, although Kaufman nonetheless has a credit score on the Doug Liman-directed model set for launch from Lionsgate subsequent yr. However Zemeckis was initially focused on taking it on.

“What happened with Robert Zemeckis was that I wrote a first draft of ‘Chaos Walking,’ and then I guess he read it and was interested in directing it,” Kaufman stated. Lionsgate set them up. “It was a really nice meeting,” Kaufman stated. “I had never met him before, but we had a really nice chat and came up with some solutions to some issues and that was the end of it. Then I didn’t end up moving forward with it, and neither did he.”

I'm Thinking of Ending Things

“I’m Thinking of Ending Things”


Alright, again to that cringe-worthy dinner. Why do the dad and mom preserve altering?

Over the course of a really creepy night, Jake’s dad and mom bear a sequence of dramatic bodily adjustments, from younger to previous and again once more. Jake is mainly residing by way of the various levels of his dad and mom’ lives, a course of that has sophisticated the thought of bringing his new girlfriend dwelling. The place does he place her in that timeline? He can’t discover the proper second, as a result of it doesn’t exist. As a lot as he desires to remain in the home along with her, they ultimately depart, at her insistence.

So begins one other lengthy automotive journey. And…was {that a} Pauline Kael impersonation?

Whereas at Jake’s home, Lucy wanders into his childhood bed room. It’s strewn with piles of flicks, books, and different materials. One quantity stands out: “For Keeps: 30 Years at the Movies,” a 1996 number of former New Yorker movie critic Pauline Kael’s critiques (the ebook, now out of print, attracts from a number of earlier collections). As soon as again on the highway, Lucy and Jake have interaction in a loooooong, meandering dialogue that bursts with intellectual references, from Man Debord’s “Society as Spectacle” to Goethe’s concept of colour and a David Foster Wallace essay from the gathering “A Supposedly Fun Thing I’ll Never Do Again.”

All of those fragments level to sophisticated concepts associated to Jake’s obsessions, however none obtain extra display screen time than a Pauline Kael assessment — her 1974 takedown of John Cassavetes’ “Woman Under the Influence.” (Unusually, that assessment shouldn’t be included in “For Keeps.”)

A Woman Under The Influence (1974)Directed by John CassavetesShown: Gena Rowlands

“A Woman Under the Influence”

Faces Worldwide / Photofest

Debating the movie and its Gena Rowlands efficiency, Lucy mainly transforms into Kael, repeating the assessment verbatim with a spot-on Kael impersonation. “I’ve always liked her, and grew up with her and reading her, and thinking that she was smarter than I am,” stated Kaufman, echoing the sentiment of many readers over time. Jake appears to be one among them: After Lucy finishes her monologue in regards to the film, which he favored, he’s left speechless.

“That goes toward the idea of Jake not being able to have anything that he wants,” Kaufman stated. “He had this opinion about that movie, and then failed. It’s an experience I’ve had — the idea that you like something, and then you read something by somebody that you really admire, and you feel like an idiot for liking that thing.” (Additionally notable: Kaufman’s current novel, “Antkind,” is in regards to the plight of a movie critic.)

What’s up with Tulsey City Ice Cream?

Finally, the automotive journey is interrupted by a cease at Tusley City Ice Cream, an invented small-town ice cream chain inexplicably open in the course of a debilitating snowstorm. On the best way over, Jesse and Lucy recall the jingle for the ice cream store commercials. The pair cease there briefly and Lucy has a cryptic interplay with three girls behind the takeout counter. Two of them are giggly and flirtatious, whereas a 3rd appears terrified.

In response to Kaufman, they’re all references to girls that Jake has seen earlier than. “Then there was this idea that there were many generations of high-school kids who worked there that he had interacted with over the years and had his problems with,” Kaufman stated. “It’s a dreamy stop into his psyche, into his past.”

Within the ebook, the couple really cease at a Dairy Queen. “We weren’t able to get the rights to use that, so I changed it,” Kaufman stated. “But I think it worked out better, because it’s more mysterious, and because it’s more local.”

Let’s discuss that dance sequence.

After they park at the highschool, Jake runs inside, indignant that the janitor is watching from afar. When Lucy goes after him, she has a heat encounter with the janitor through which he sends her on his manner — suggesting that the character has lastly accepted that he should half methods together with his fantasy. Elaborating on this concept, Lucy and Jake then spot one another in a hallway, the place they’re changed by a pair of ballet dancers sporting their garments. Over the following a number of minutes, they have interaction in a energetic piece of choreography patterned after the same second within the musical “Oklahoma!”

Earlier within the film, the janitor passes a faculty recital of the play, which incorporates an in depth “dream ballet” sequence that finds the farm lady Laurey on the heart of a brawl between two suitors, Curly McLain and Jud Fry. That sequence ends with Curly’s loss of life; right here, it’s the Jake stand-in who goes down, suggesting that Jake has accepted the impossibility of his love.

“There’s a few things in ‘Oklahoma!’ that felt like they were really kind of thematically parallel to the story that we were telling,” Kaufman stated. As for the dream sequence: “I was always intrigued by it, because it’s so creepy, and I liked the idea of the doppelgänger aspect in it.” In different phrases, Jake has been pretending he’s another person, and makes use of the narrative framework of “Oklahoma!” to get rid of that delusion.

After which there’s the speaking animated pig.

Really, one other one which’s fairly easy. In his automotive, the janitor appears to have an assault of some kind, and probably dies. Like Charles Foster Kane whispering “Rosebud” from his mattress, janitor-Jake sees tidbits from his youth within the windshield, together with the animated “Tulsey Town Ice Cream” advert referenced earlier. These give approach to an animated pig with maggots on its abdomen — a grim encounter that Jake recounts to Lucy earlier within the film, whereas giving her a tour of the farm. The affable animal walks Jake again to his last second of introspection.

One thing in regards to the innocence of the pig and its horrific underbelly traumatized Jake early in life. In his previous age, he has come to phrases with this elementary imbalance within the universe.

Within the final scene, everybody’s previous. However it appears sort of…pretend.

Onstage to just accept an award within the film’s last scene, Jake stands towards a backdrop of the “Oklahoma!” set, sporting apparent stage make-up to appear to be an previous man. However he’s not alone. It’s a packed home, and everybody within the room — together with his dad and mom and Lucy — are sporting the identical make-up. Initially, Kaufman included a tidbit to clarify this inclusion.

“There was a scene where the janitor found a makeup book in the bathroom as he was cleaning up, because somebody had clearly been putting their makeup on in this boys or girls room,” Kaufman stated. The machine permits Jake to convey everybody in his head to age together with him, whereas reminding us of the artifice in play. “All of the people who were in the audience, with the exception of the characters from the movie, are the extras who played high school kids in the rest of the movie,” Kaufman stated. “So they’re all young people wearing old-age makeup.”

Is that…the closing speech from “A Beautiful Mind”?

Yup. When Jake accepts his prize, he recites the sentimental Nobel Prize speech delivered by economist John Nash (Russell Crowe) on the finish of Ron Howard’s Oscar winner. Actually, your complete sequence has been constructed to resemble the conclusion of the 2001 film.

Earlier in “I’m Thinking of Ending Things,” a DVD of “A Beautiful Mind” is glimpsed in Jake’s room, so it stands to motive that Jake discovered a lot relatable in regards to the story of an excellent man who struggles with paranoid schizophrenia and has hassle checking out the fact surrounding him. Kaufman was cautious of spelling that out, although.

“That’s one that I’m not as comfortable talking about because it does get to the meat of what the movie I made is about,” he stated, however then elaborated anyway. “This movie is dealing with somebody’s experience of absorbing things that they see and how they become part of his psyche,” he stated. “So this was in some ways how this person might have fantasized it out.”

After all, there could also be extra to this: Finish credit declare that the speech was lifted with permission of the studio, however Kaufman performed no position in that. In contrast to Zemeckis, he didn’t ask for Howard’s blessing. “I have certainly never spoken to Ron Howard in my life,” Kaufman stated. “I’m assuming they got permission.”

Contemplating that “A Beautiful Mind” was one of many cheesier Oscar winners of the earlier decade (and it gained the identical yr that “Adaptation” got here out), it’s no large leap to see the inclusion as an enormous cinematic eyeroll in regards to the deceptive nature of storytelling that clouds the true nature of solipsistic struggles. “A Beautiful Mind” places a cheerful ending on that topic; in “I’m Thinking of Ending of Things,” the wrestle by no means ends.

After which Jake sings…

Yep, extra of “Oklahoma!” Sitting down on a set that appears like a replica of his childhood bed room, he delivers a melancholic rendition of “Lonely Room,” through which Jud declares his intention of marrying Laurey. The tune contains the telling line, “Get me a woman to call my own.” Dream on, Jud — and Jake, it appears. “The character of Jud seemed to be comparable in some ways to Jake,” Kaufman stated. Sitting on a set constructed from the fragments that outline his life, Jake has change into the star of his personal story and concurrently confined by it.

And that’s it! Proper?

Not fairly. That last picture of the janitor’s snow-encrusted automotive primarily means that janitor-Jake died there at midnight. It’s a stupendous, tragic capper to a narrative about one man confronting the failures of his life because it leaves his physique. Kaufman hopes that folks preserve watching by way of the credit, which record lots of the references all through the film. “There’s actually a lot of stuff in the end credits that’s important to me,” Kaufman stated. “It’s an intentional thing, the way it plays out.”

Exhausted? Possibly, however the riddles of the film all serve a objective. In the end, Kaufman doesn’t assume that “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” hides a lot from its viewers. “The way I was presenting it was that you would probably figure it out,” he stated. “This is what the character is going through. You either get it or you don’t.”

“I’m Thinking of Ending Things” is now streaming on Netflix.

Signal Up: Keep on high of the most recent breaking movie and TV information! Join our Electronic mail Newsletters right here.

Filmy Online


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here